The science of getting off sugar

Why you crave it—and how to successfully reduce sugar intake

If you've ever tried to cut out sugar and found yourself giving in to a donut at the office or that candy bar in the checkout aisle, you're not alone. Most people think that overcoming sugar cravings is all about willpower. But what if I told you it’s not a lack of discipline? It’s actually biology.

Let’s dive into what’s really going on behind those sugar cravings so we can talk about how to actually reduce those sugar cravings once and for all.

---

The common scenario

You start the week with the best intentions: no sugar. But then life happens. Someone brings in pastries to the office, you walk by a bakery, or you’re just tired at the end of the day and that sweet treat is calling your name. You give in, and suddenly it feels like a failure of willpower.

In an effort to do better, you might switch to non-nutritive sweeteners, thinking that if there’s no sugar, there's no problem. But often, you notice the cravings stay the same—or even get worse.

This is where it’s easy to think it’s all about self-control. But let’s break down the science to understand what’s really happening.

---

The science

When you eat something sweet—whether it’s sugar or a sugar substitute—your brain releases dopamine, a neurotransmitter that signals pleasure and reward. This dopamine hit happens almost instantly, even before your body starts digesting anything. It’s the taste of sweetness—not the actual sugar content—that triggers this response.

Over time, as you consume more sweet-tasting foods and drinks, your brain and taste buds adapt. You start to need more sweetness to get that same pleasurable feeling. This is why cutting out sugar completely can feel so challenging—your brain is used to that reward, and it’s looking for that same hit, even if it comes from a zero-calorie sweetener.

---

It’s about sweeteness, not just sugar

This means that swapping sugar for artificial sweeteners isn’t always the solution. The sweetness itself can keep those cravings alive.

So what can you do instead? Let’s talk about a more balanced approach—one that’s realistic and sustainable.

---

A balanced approach to reducing sugar

You don’t need to cut sugar completely or go all-in overnight. The real magic happens when you shift gradually, with changes that are realistic and sustainable.

Here’s what that can look like:

1. Start small and cut back gradually

You don’t have to overhaul everything at once. Start by dialing down added sugars and sweeteners slowly.
→ Swap one soda for sparkling water with a squeeze of lemon or lime, or an Olipop
→ Replace dessert a few nights a week with fruit and yogurt
→ Cut the sweetener in your coffee in half, then again next week

Small steps lower your sweetness threshold over time—without the overwhelm. The more you reduce the more you’ll adapt to needing less sweetener over time. It takes just 2 weeks to reset your taste buds!

---

2. Prioritize protein and fiber

If you’re not eating enough protein—especially in the morning—cravings will feel more intense later in the day. A high-protein breakfast (like eggs, Greek yogurt, or a protein shake) can reduce sugar cravings by up to 300% in some studies.

Fiber plays a key role, too. It slows digestion, keeps you full, and helps regulate blood sugar.
Add high-fiber foods to most meals: basil seeds, leafy greens, beans, chia, berries, or ground flax.

---

3. Hydrate strategically

Even mild dehydration can show up as sugar cravings or low energy.

Try adding a pinch of sea salt or a squeeze of lemon to your water—especially after sweating, traveling, or when you’re feeling foggy in the afternoon.

---

4. Plan for real life

This might be the most important shift.

Take a moment to think:
→ When do your cravings usually hit?
→ Is it pastries at the office? That 3pm dip? A reward at the end of a stressful day?

Once you spot the pattern, you can plan for it.
Bring a protein-rich snack you actually enjoy. Keep something satisfying on hand for those habitual moments. If sugar is how you self-soothe, what else might help support your nervous system in the moment? (A walk, music, a warm drink, a call to a friend?)

Cravings lose their power when you take away the element of surprise.

---

5. Rethink the habit loop

Sweet cravings aren’t just physical—they’re behavioral.

Notice the rhythm:
→ Do you always want something sweet with coffee?
→ Does dessert signal the end of your day?
→ Is it hunger—or just a routine your brain expects?

You don’t have to eliminate the habit—just shift it.
Pair your coffee with a high-protein breakfast. Replace the after-dinner sweet with something warm and grounding. Change the cue, and you can change the craving.

---

TL;DR

Sugar cravings aren’t a personal failure. They’re a mix of biology, behavior, and habit.

But once you understand the pattern, you can change it.

Reset your taste buds by reducing sugar over time. Stabilize your blood sugar with protein and fiber rich meals. Plan ahead for the moments that usually throw you off.

And give yourself grace—this isn’t about perfection. It’s about small shifts, done consistently, that support your body and brain in feeling better.

You don’t have to white-knuckle your way off sugar. You just need a smarter strategy!